MeadesShrine has become a regular port of call for me on YouTube; it's a collection of all of the Raybanned one's investigations going back to the early 1990s. MeadesShrine became particularly indispensable this weekend when it posted, within hours of transmission, episode 1 of Off Kilter, the new Meades series about the architecture of Scotland, being shown on BBC 4. Meades begins in Aberdeen, a city I spent four years in, and recently revisited, an experience I found surprisingly powerful, partly for the reasons Meades details in Off Kilter: the fact that Aberdeen is so different from anywhere else in Britain, and that it's so suffused with the irreducible otherness of a vanished past.
My time in The Granite City was in the era of The Iron Lady, but my friends Emma and Joe were there much more recently -- right before they moved to Berlin earlier this year -- so I heard at first hand (Emma was employed by Peacock) all about the tussle between Peacock -- Aberdeen's most distinguished contemporary art space -- and oil magnate Sir Ian Wood. The sordid tale comes up 4.34 minutes into this chunk of Off Kilter:
It's worth quoting Meades' account: "There is currently a proposal to effect a wholesale transformation of Aberdeen's very core. A couple of years ago a discreet, elegant scheme was devised by Brisac Gonzalez architects to create on -- or rather in -- this slope a largely subterranean home for the Peacock visual arts centre.
"No sooner had it been granted planning permission than Sir Ian Wood, a billionaire oil tycoon with £50M to spare, countered with his grandiose vision: to cover this valley with a vast roof, and on that roof create a public space which would be a cross between "a mini Central Park and a grand Italian piazza". And beneath that roof? Wood's vision is excitingly 20th century. There'd be a car park. And a shopping mall."
Meades is not impressed: "Where does one start? With the fact that this intervention -- philanthropic or plutocratic, according to taste -- is, let us say, most unorthodox? With Peacock having lost part of its funding because its project has been put in abeyance? With the fawning of the city council and the Scottish government, and the intensely relaxed Alex Salmond's enthusiasm? With the catch in the small print -- Wood expects the rate-payers to stump up another £50M to achieve his glorious vision? Besides all this, the last thing Aberdeen needs is more shops. No, come to think of it, the last thing Aberdeen needs is an enormous car park that will merely increase the volume of traffic." (Peacock's page about the debacle is here.)
Later, Meades gives Donald Trump a deserved shafting too. The quiffed American hopes to build a "Trumptown-on-Sea" near Aberdeen (pity the poor town with oil; slicks and scum are sure to follow!), but Meades hopes that the financial crisis may have a silver lining: the stumping and stymieing of both these projects.
"Do not build," suggests Meades. Instead -- over images of the folksy Footdee -- he suggests we should "bodge, make-do and mend." It's a theme that came up in Zak Kyes' recent lecture in Berlin, in which he reported receiving a text message from Archigram guru David Greene which simply said "declare a moratorium on building". Sure, but not before we've completed our digital shrine to Meades.